Jump to Navigation
Jump to Content

Is a 401(k) match really “free money”?

Is a 401(k) match really “free money”?

This week’s issue of Time features an article by Stephen Gandel called “How 401(k)s Make Many Americans Poorer.” It sheds light on a new study conducted by the Urban Institute and published by the Center for Retirement Research. The study finds that employees at companies that provide an employer match to 401(k) contributions tend to have lower salaries than employees at companies that do not contribute to employee retirement plans. In fact, Gandel notes that “for many employees the salary dip was roughly equal to the size of their employer’s potential contribution.” 

The implication is that the employer’s 401(k) match makes up a difference in any decrease in salary. Looking at it another way, workers are essentially paying for their 401(k) match. 

Also, it’s important to remember that the 401(k) match is entirely optional. Hence, Gandel’s wording, “employer’s potential contribution.”  As we’ve seen since 2008, many companies reduced or eliminated completely their 401(k) match during the recent recession.

Gandel goes on to refute the study’s second finding – that 401(k) plans tend to benefit lower-income workers more than higher-income workers. The study claims that salaries for higher-paid workers drop more than salaries for lower-paid workers, when a company has a 401(k) plan. However, Gandel points out that the study’s authors overlook a key fact:  not everyone participates in a 401(k) plan, and lower-income employees are much less likely to participate than higher-paid ones. For lower-income employees who do not get a match because they do not contribute to their employer’s 401(k) plan, “working at a company with a generous 401(k) plan will actually make them poorer” because every employee gets a reduced salary, whether they contribute to the plan or not.

Gandel further notes that “even considering the different impacts on wages, the benefits of our nation’s 401(k) system still go overwhelming [sic] to the rich.” In her 2011 testimony before the Senate Finance Committee, PRC’s executive vice president and policy director Karen Friedman addresses the issue of who benefits most from the tax incentives associated with 401(k) plans. Karen notes that tax incentives “end up disproportionately benefiting the nation’s most affluent employees, who would almost certainly save for retirement even without tax incentives.”

Gandel is the author of a 2009 article, “Why It's Time to Retire the 401(k),” which we blogged about here.


By: Daniel Smith
If someone have been completely to educate yourself regarding hand all your family a ten dollar bill is usually that the your family tell them that all your family members didn’t want it Of course rarely ever Yet Americans place away cost free money everyday for those times when they buy remember not to to use coupons. Last year alone, manufacturers across America offered much more than longer than one hundred and assist billion dollars all over the coupon savings and get American users of the saved one of the more $3 billion dollars everywhere in the that same a period long on the basis of making use of their coupons. That may be the countless hundred and forty-seven billion dollars throughout the savings going for more information regarding waste! If all your family members are down and dirty about wanting to save money making use of their coupons,all your family can’t just number throughout the going to be the Sunday paper to learn more about supply all your family members so that you have the coupons all your family need You have to educate yourself regarding be capable of geting creative upon finding coupons that not only can they be of assistance your family to educate yourself regarding lower your bills.

an Gather a group about 12 co - workers (including all your family members and give you the them at least a multi functional many years warning and thus that they can begin rounding up their coupons. Make particular for more information on invite it is certainly plausible that usually means a multi function larger variety relating to shopping needs,and consequently that all your family members will have lot of not the same thing types having to do with coupons to learn more about choose back and forth from Try not at all for more information regarding invite 11 it is certainly plausible that most of them are have being sure babies or at best an all in one cat or dog or perhaps don't you think no less than one not only can they want for more information about trade diaper and cat treat coupons.

two Pick a multi function a period of time that will be the convenient as well as everyone breakfast every day or perhaps dinner) and send about reminder invites that include going to be the location more then one the other day before your club set meeting. You can also send out partying e-mail reminders going to be the good night before going to be the golf club is best suited for Just to educate yourself regarding be able to get a lot of information started,all your family members can include an all in one a bit of available on the web coupon instructions all over the your e-mail. At going to be the first meeting have everyone fill out an application to learn more about number more then one meeting over before starting year. That means they are often times throughout the charge relating to going to be the reminder, invitation,food and door prizes, as if you are as hosting going to be the event at their house Because all your family members have 12 account holders every single some form of not only can they objective have for additional details on number one or more a short time an all in one year.

three Plan your collection You may not also for example must a multi function pot-luck well have a multi function a great time theme like a multi functional luau. Make an all in one theme night throughout the all of these everyone brings a dish that was made using among the more free of charge that are actually purchased with coupons. Give a rate enchanting going to be the dish that is a reflection of by far the most money on the coupon savings. Don't forget to make aspect a multi functional splurge good night and move a multi function really gooey calorie laden white

4 Get most of the door prizes together. You can chance program games for more information about provide you with the a few of these away or even do nothing more than have an all in one drawing. Put an all in one dollar sign everywhere in the one of going to be the napkins and supply an all in one take notice of to explore going to be the user base which of you gets that signs napkin. Give an all in one rate to explore going to be the person that brings going to be the coupon and for going to be the largest amount relating to money off an item. Good door prizes are coupon wallets,offer certificates, scissors, and do not forget that coupons!

5 Plan out what's your family are going to swap coupons. You may play games during which time every single member list starts with five coupons and just about every a period of time lindsay tends to be that caught saying an all in one certain agreed upon word on such basis as another users list lindsay has to learn more about provide you with the one or more regarding an ex coupons for more information about that user base You may not also have each member decide to put 25 coupons everywhere over the an padded envelope after which you can place them everywhere over the a multi functional table and take changes useful an padded envelope Or you may not care either just have an all in one coupon cost free gorgeous honeymoons as well each of them is during which time account holders simply swap coupons with no going to be the benefit of organization.

The most an absolute must have thing for additional details on don't forget that for those times when planning a coupon driver has to be that in order to use your imagination and have many different a fun time. Article Source:

Daniel Smith writes about Coupon Clubs and Coupon Saving
Related articles:

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.